Reply
Visitor
AGogley
Posts: 2
Registered: ‎09-02-2010
0

Failed Long test but now passing...should I RMA?

A couple weeks ago I had a BSOD. Prior thereto, no problems that I recall.  I was able to recover and boot into windows but it never worked properly.  I thought it must be a registry or driver corruption error, so I reinstalled windows.  Everything worked great for about a week and a half.  Then I was using the computer and a BSOD hit.  I couldn't boot after that, not even into Safe mode.  I figured it was hardware.  I reformatted the drive and reinstalled windows.  Everything is running, although I haven't updated drivers yet.

 

I ran Seatools for windows.  All the short tests passed but the long DST failed.  I was issued a special code for RMA.  So I ran the Seatools for DOS using a CD.  Both short and long tests passed.  Now I've run the Seatools for Windows and everything is passing now.  So now I can't decide whether to RMA or not.

 

I've also run Memtest overnight and it stopped with one error at 130% coverage.  I haven't had a chance to start pulling out sticks and running them one at a time yet to see if there is a RAM error (or worse).

 

Should I RMA the hard-drive regardless of the memtest results?  I'm inclined to think that any fail would be a signal of degradation and ultimate replacement.  On the other hand, getting a refurbished drive doesn't exactly excite me either.

 

Aaron

 

Shuttle SX48P2 E

Intel Core Duo 3.12GHZ Wolfdale

Corsair 4x1GB DDR2 6400 with 5-5-5-12 timings

EVGA 8800 GTS

Seagate 7200.11 640 GB

WD Caviar SE16 320GB

Windows 7 Ultimate