Reply
Yottabyte
fzabkar
Posts: 4,656
Registered: ‎01-27-2009
0

Re: How often does your hard drive "chirp"?

I wasn't offering an opinion as to whether this feature is desirable or otherwise, I was merely confirming that this head parking behaviour is by design, ie it is not a defect. WD's drives behave this way as well. FWIW, I prefer to have full control over my drive's power management settings, but I believe that there are certain situations where APM would be desirable, for example if the drive were in an external enclosure attached to a TV. That said, there are USB enclosures where the bridge IC inside the enclosure spins the drive up or down as required rather than the drive itself. Moreover, some bridge firmware actually issues an ATA APM command to the drive immediately after power on. You could easily configure your desktop or laptop to do exactly the same thing.

To this end, I would bite the bullet and use hdparm to disable APM, or reduce its aggressiveness. AIUI, your drive's APM settings are volatile, ie they don't survive a power cycle, so you will need to do this after every cold boot. You could place an appropriate hdparm command line in a CMD or BAT file in your StartUp group. This will result in hdparm being executed automatically at bootup, after which it will terminate and exit. In this way there will be absolutely no impact on your system's resources.

In fact, if I were in your shoes, I would be just as concerned, perhaps more so, about the mysterious task that is accessing your drive each minute, apparently without your knowledge. I'm not a Windows 7 user, but I would look in Task Manager and terminate likely suspects until this annoying behaviour stops.

Kilobyte
vsm1966
Posts: 19
Registered: ‎06-18-2012
0

Re: How often does your hard drive "chirp"?

Hello,

 

Do not be fooled.

 

Replacement the HD as soon as possible and do not trust Seatool, the seatool will say that the HD is in perfect condition, until one day turn on the computer and no longer works.

 

Replacement the HD is the only solution, as many times as necessary until you send an HD without problems. 

 

Is it you money.

Regular Visitor
husky55
Posts: 4
Registered: ‎07-25-2012
0

Re: How often does your hard drive "chirp"?

It all depends on how you use your drives.  I would assume that it's normal and even preferred that the APM i.e. chirping noise is ON. It's due to the head parking of the drive. It reduces heat and power.

 

I took my ST3000DM001 out of the enclosure ( because of prices) to use in servers. I can reduce or eliminate the chirp noise or set APM to OFF by using hdparm.

 

Whether this is recommended by Seagate I do not know. May be somebody from Seagate engineering can enlighten us?