05-28-2009 07:38 AM
The subject item was recently returned for repair or replacement. This is second unit that has failed for me within half a year. The unit was returned with no action taken because someone believed the unit had been tampered with. Here’s the situation. The unit runs quite hot [my experience and noted in product reviews by others] and I placed four small rubber feet on the bottom of the device in an attempt to promote better airflow by convection through the bottom vent slots. Lower temperatures promote a more favorable MTBF. When the unit failed [AGAIN] I removed the feet and sent it back. A small piece of the screw cover warranty sticker adhered to the adhesive of the rubber foot. Photos provided to Seagate for review.
Why would I be compelled to tamper with a unit that has a 5-year warranty and is only several months old? The screw is not even completely uncovered. On the other hand, perhaps the warranty duration doesn’t correlate well with Seagate’s expected reliability of the unit. On that basis, I can see why Seagate is inclined to deny warranty claims for a product that clearly has a large number of field problems. This web users’ forum confirms this!
This product has been a huge waste of time for me. I have greatly diminished confidence in this product as well as Seagate / Maxtor as a company.
Any suggestions on recovering or salvaging useful or reusable parts from this device?
05-28-2009 09:07 AM
If the failure is in the CPU side of the drive you can remove the HD and use it in another system. You should call Seagate and try to get a better resolution to your issue. Opening the enclosure requires more than just removing the warranty sticker and would show other signs of tampering. The software is open source and based on FreeNAS. You might look at building a FreeNAS box if you liked the features of the Central Axis.
05-28-2009 09:26 AM
Thanks for the reply. I tried several times to get someone at Seagate to take a more rational approach to my dilemma. Here's their final decision.
I apologize for the inconvenience, but after review ofthe pictures and the typed statement from you, we will not be able to replaceyour drive. The "tampering"they were referring to is the feet you put on the drive. You put a couple of them over the label; morespecifically the serial number. We willnot be able to replace your drive; your warranty is voided. The drive will be returned to you again.
What is the procedure for extracting the drive? If the drive is any good, I suppose I could recover half of the original purchase price of the unit.
05-28-2009 08:07 PM
My units are 700 mile a way so this is from memory. There are 2 screws under the back rubber strip and 2 by the void warranty sticker. The metal sides are glued on. I would remove at least 1 to see what you are doing (they can be glued back on). There are catchs on the front and back of the middle section. The middle drops down.( I broke my tabs, but it doesn't affect putting the unit back together) . The Thermal pads on the side of the drive might catch when removing the drive. (this is why it is good to remove the side). The cover over the lights comes off also.
Once the drive is out start removing screws until you get to the drive out. You will need to unplug and unscrew one of the small circuit boards to get to the drive. The drive is formatted as Ext3 which is readable with ubuntu, reformat for windows or mac. I would recommend getting a Thermaltake SATA dock or simular item to use the drive externally.
I'll update this when I get back to look at my drive.
I disassembled one of my units because I was curious not because it was broken. (Warranty Void)
Good Luck.
06-02-2009 09:16 PM
12-26-2010 11:17 AM
everrest wrote:My units are 700 mile a way so this is from memory. There are 2 screws under the back rubber strip and 2 by the void warranty sticker. The metal sides are glued on. I would remove at least 1 to see what you are doing (they can be glued back on). There are catchs on the front and back of the middle section. The middle drops down.( I broke my tabs, but it doesn't affect putting the unit back together) . The Thermal pads on the side of the drive might catch when removing the drive. (this is why it is good to remove the side). The cover over the lights comes off also.
Once the drive is out start removing screws until you get to the drive out. You will need to unplug and unscrew one of the small circuit boards to get to the drive. The drive is formatted as Ext3 which is readable with ubuntu, reformat for windows or mac. I would recommend getting a Thermaltake SATA dock or simular item to use the drive externally.
I'll update this when I get back to look at my drive.
I disassembled one of my units because I was curious not because it was broken. (Warranty Void)
Good Luck.
Since I'm writing a year after your comment, you may not be following this thread any longer, but I thought I'd try.
Which model were you talking about? My Central Axis is 9GY5A8-500. I don't see any visible screws at all and the sides appear to be plastic rather than metal. I'd like to try pulling out the drives to see if they're still ok and would like to do as little violence to the device as possible.
12-26-2010 05:31 PM
NMadson wrote:
Since I'm writing a year after your comment, you may not be following this thread any longer, but I thought I'd try.
Which model were you talking about? My Central Axis is 9GY5A8-500. I don't see any visible screws at all and the sides appear to be plastic rather than metal. I'd like to try pulling out the drives to see if they're still ok and would like to do as little violence to the device as possible.
After a few more searches I found detailed instructions - WITH photos - on how to remove the drive from a Maxtor Central Access: http://www.davesieg.com/?p=182. I don't have the requisite background Dave suggests one needs before trying this process, but this has become an academic exercise for me more than a practical necessity.
12-28-2010 02:08 PM
Yes, just spent the past few hours on the phone with 3 different people at seagate to your same end, "We will not help you and don't call back. Good luck taking your drive apart. I will wait a few years and hope the lights go out and I can send them back under warranty. Paperweights to bookends, central axis not compatible with Snow Leopard
12-28-2010 01:59 PM
I am the proud owners of a set of 4 new, never used central axis (M# 9GY5A8-500) bookends. That is according to seagate, as they informed me that there is no way to make them work with Snow Leopard (10.6). You see, I waited too long to set them up and find that they are incompatible with Snow Leopard. My 30 days are up so the 4 units are mine to keep. Though I do have the 5 year warranty that I could use if they were to fail. Only not being able to use the drives, it will be hard to know when they do fail. On the bright side, I will never lose any data when they do fail. My only recourse is to downgrade my OS back to Leopard (10.5) or get a PC.
Does anyone know of a work around where I can access these drives with Snow Leopard?
©2012 Seagate Technology LLC