Hi,
I have just bought a Maxtor One-touch 4 Plus 500GB drive last weekend, and a Freeagent desktop 500 GB drive on Black Friday. I too have questions about the Maxtor's drive status light on front of Maxtor drive. I have windows vista business, and have installed the maxtor manager software. My light on my Maxtor drive stays lighted constant when I am on my computer, then when accessing drive, it will blink. I have seen intermittant blinking only after long time of not accessing the drive, maybe that is a resting state.
I keep both my drives plugged in and on.
Now last night, I had the usual windows automatic updates, and the computer rebooted by itself, the Maxtor drive did not turn back on. I unplugged and replugged the drive and it came back on fine and I check drive manager and it says drive is recognized, and I see the folders fine. Now I went to work today and my computer was on all day, I do not use windows sleep mode. I come home and the Maxtor drive was powered off again, by itself... how did it do that? So I had to go and unplug the drive and plug in the drive, now the drive is on, but how to trust it at all? There is no power switch. Does this drive turn itself off normally? This would be unusual. I would like answers to questions about this drive's power settings and configurations for power and the inconsistant white light status on the front.
I also have a FreeAgent Desktop 500GB drive and its software drive manager. It also does not have a power switch. The FreeAgent drive goes into some kind of rest state and the yellow bar dims when not in use. The yellow bar pulsates dim to bright when accessing this drive. This drive stays on when windows Vista Reboots due to an update. However I have heard this drive has weakness with its power controller, so I try to keep it plugged in all the time, and I have not yet had any problem with this drive turning off by itself.
The Freeagent drive manager software recognizes the Maxtor one-touch 4 drive in it's drive status and the Maxtor drive manager does not see the Freeagent drive, which is well and good since the One-Touch software has different backup features. I do not use any of the backup software provided by either drive, I do my own backup manually, and I keep copies of all my files on my main computer drive and also backed up to DVD or CD disks as well.
Both drives are about the same temperature when in use, and the Freeagent drive is a bit quieter (I found it has a SATA drive inside), the Maxtor drive makes more hard drive access noise (what type of drive is inside?).
Both these drives were purchased to replace an old Maxtor OneTouch III 350 GB drive that suffered from "the drive is corrupt and unreadable, do you want to format this drive" syndrome. That drive had goofy character next to drive letter, and also in event viewer stated that it was corrupt and unreadable. I had to use disk recovery software on that drive.